Every concrete project eventually hits the same question: mix it yourself from bags, or call a ready-mix truck? The answer depends mostly on volume. Here is how to decide.
Start with the volume
Work out cubic feet and cubic yards with the concrete slab calculator, or the concrete bag calculator for posts and steps. Then compare against this:
| Bag size | Yield per bag | Bags per cubic yard | Weight per cubic yard |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 lb | 0.30 cu ft | 90 | 3,600 lb |
| 60 lb | 0.45 cu ft | 60 | 3,600 lb |
| 80 lb | 0.60 cu ft | 45 | 3,600 lb |
Yields from Quikrete product data sheets; other brands are similar.
A single cubic yard is 45 bags of 80 lb, about 1.8 tons to haul, lift, mix and place. That is the number to keep in mind.
When bags make sense
- Under about 1 cubic yard: fence and deck posts, footings, small pads, steps, repairs.
- Jobs done in stages, such as one post hole at a time.
- Hard-to-reach spots where a truck can’t get close and you don’t want to pay for a pump.
- Fast-setting needs: fast-setting bagged mixes can set posts in under an hour.
When ready-mix makes sense
- Over about 1–2 cubic yards: patios, driveways, garage floors, shed bases.
- Slabs that need a consistent finish. Every batch from a mixer is slightly different, and batches placed minutes apart don’t bond as one pour. Ready-mix arrives uniform and can be placed in one continuous pour.
- Specified strength or mix. Plants can supply exact strengths, air-entrainment for freeze-thaw areas, fibers, accelerators or retarders.
Cost: a simple comparison
Prices vary a lot by region, so plug in your local quotes. The pattern is consistent:
- Bags have no minimum, but the cost per yard is high: about 45 bags at your local price, plus mixer rental and many hours of labor.
- Ready-mix is usually much cheaper per yard, but many plants have a minimum order or a short-load fee for small orders (often under about 4–5 yards). There may also be fees if unloading takes longer than the allowed time.
On a 1.5 yard patio, a short-load fee can make the truck cost similar to bags. But the truck saves a full day of mixing and gives a better slab. Ask for an all-in quote.
Questions to ask your ready-mix supplier
- What is your minimum order, and what is the short-load fee?
- How much unloading time is included, and what does overtime cost?
- What strength (psi) do you recommend for my use and climate? Should it be air-entrained?
- Can the truck reach my forms? How close does the driveway let it get, and how much does it weigh?
- Do I need a pump or a wheelbarrow crew for the distance?
Practical tips either way
- Order 5–10% extra. Bases are never perfectly flat.
- Have help ready. A cubic yard of concrete placed in summer heat gives you limited working time.
- Check the weather. Avoid freezing temperatures, and plan for curing in hot weather.
- Prepare a washout spot for tools and the chute, away from drains.
Use the slab calculator to see both options side by side for your exact slab.